Justia Criminal Law Opinion Summaries

by
In 2001, Clifton Terrell attempted to rob two individuals in San Francisco, resulting in the fatal shooting of one victim, Hunter McPherson. Terrell was convicted by a jury in 2005 of murder with a special circumstance of murder during an attempted robbery, as well as other related robbery offenses. He received a sentence of life without parole and additional terms for firearm use. Terrell later alleged that the special circumstance finding and sentence were imposed on the basis of race, referencing statistical reports that suggested significant racial disparities in San Francisco’s charging and sentencing under the relevant statutes.After his conviction was affirmed on appeal, Terrell filed a petition in the San Francisco County Superior Court seeking appointment of counsel and discovery to pursue a habeas corpus claim under the California Racial Justice Act. The trial court denied both requests, reasoning that Terrell’s allegations were too broad and conclusory and that the statistical evidence he presented did not sufficiently relate to his specific conduct or offense. The court found Terrell had not plausibly alleged a violation of the Racial Justice Act nor established good cause for discovery.Reviewing the case, the California Court of Appeal, First Appellate District, Division One, held that Terrell’s petition met the minimal pleading requirement to secure counsel under the Racial Justice Act. The court clarified that the threshold for appointment of counsel is extremely low and does not require a prima facie showing of a specific violation, but only a plausible allegation. The court issued a writ of mandate directing the trial court to vacate its denial, appoint counsel for Terrell, and conduct a new hearing on any discovery motions brought by counsel. The disposition was a grant of the writ of mandate. View "Terrell v. Super. Ct." on Justia Law

by
A seventeen-year-old defendant was charged with felony murder, attempted robbery, and conspiracy to commit robbery in Indiana. Due to the seriousness of the charges, his case was directly filed in adult criminal court. He ultimately pled guilty to felony murder, accepting a fixed forty-five-year sentence, which was the statutory minimum, in exchange for the dismissal of the other charges. At the time of his plea and sentencing, neither his attorney nor the court informed him about a recently enacted Indiana law that allowed for discretionary alternative sentencing for juveniles tried in adult court. The defendant later learned of this possibility and argued that his attorney's failure to advise him constituted ineffective assistance of counsel.After his sentencing, the defendant filed for postconviction relief in Indiana state court, proceeding pro se. His trial counsel testified that she was unaware of any alternative sentencing eligibility and believed forty-five years was the minimum. The postconviction court denied relief, finding no factual support for the ineffective assistance claim. On appeal, the Indiana Court of Appeals affirmed the denial, incorrectly concluding that the alternative sentencing scheme was not effective at the time of sentencing. The Indiana Supreme Court declined to review the case. Subsequently, the defendant sought federal habeas corpus relief in the United States District Court for the Southern District of Indiana, which also denied relief, initially misunderstanding the effect of the fixed plea and later concluding that the trial court would not have ordered alternative sentencing.The United States Court of Appeals for the Seventh Circuit reviewed the case de novo, as the last state court decision was based on an unreasonable factual determination. The court held that the defendant failed to show prejudice under Strickland v. Washington because he did not provide contemporaneous evidence that he would have either negotiated a better plea or insisted on going to trial if properly advised. The court affirmed the district court’s denial of habeas relief. View "Rodgers v Neal" on Justia Law

by
The case involves an individual who, due to a prior Oklahoma state felony conviction for possession of marijuana, was prohibited from possessing firearms under federal law. Law enforcement responded to a domestic disturbance call, encountered the defendant, and discovered he had a gun. During the encounter, officers questioned him about any prior felony convictions, which he emphatically denied, making several specific statements asserting that his prior case had been dismissed.He was indicted in the United States District Court for the Northern District of Oklahoma for being a felon in possession of a firearm and ammunition. Before trial, the district court excluded the defendant’s statements denying his felon status as hearsay, reasoning they were “self-serving” and not subject to cross-examination. At trial, the government relied primarily on documentary evidence from the state court proceedings, which contained errors and blank sections, and there was no direct evidence that the defendant was ever informed he was a convicted felon. The jury convicted him, and he was sentenced to fifteen months’ imprisonment and three years’ supervised release. The district court denied his motions for acquittal.On appeal, the United States Court of Appeals for the Tenth Circuit addressed three arguments: exclusion of his statements, sufficiency of the evidence regarding his knowledge of felon status, and a constitutional challenge to the statute. The court held that the district court erred in excluding the defendant’s statements because they were not offered for their truth but to show his belief about his status, so they did not constitute hearsay. The court found the error was not harmless, as the statements were the only direct evidence of the knowledge element. Furthermore, the Tenth Circuit concluded the government’s evidence was insufficient to support the conviction beyond a reasonable doubt. The court reversed the conviction and remanded with instructions to vacate the judgment, barring retrial. View "United States v. Clark" on Justia Law

by
Carlos Anderson-Honeycutt was convicted of first-degree premeditated murder after the death of Brittnee Wicker, with whom he shared a home. The prosecution contended Anderson-Honeycutt premeditated the killing and attempted to disguise the crime to implicate a gang member. Anderson-Honeycutt admitted to the shooting but argued it was not premeditated, claiming emotional distress following revelations about their relationship and an altercation immediately before the shooting. After the incident, Anderson-Honeycutt fled the scene, taking various items and eventually leaving the country.The Sedgwick District Court conducted a bench trial, ultimately convicting Anderson-Honeycutt of premeditated first-degree murder. After trial, he moved for a new trial, asserting a Brady violation due to the State’s late disclosure of a video recording made by Detective Chisholm, which showed thumbnails and metadata from a neighbor’s doorbell camera. The defense argued this video might have supported his claim that the killing was not premeditated. The district court held an evidentiary hearing and found the video was not favorable or material to the defense, denying the motion for a new trial.The Supreme Court of the State of Kansas reviewed the appeal, applying abuse of discretion and de novo standards as appropriate. The court concluded that the Chisholm video was not exculpatory, as it only confirmed the number of doorbell camera recordings—a fact already established by other evidence and not material to the disputed issues at trial. The court held that suppressed evidence must itself be favorable to the accused to constitute a Brady violation, and speculation about whether other evidence could have been obtained does not satisfy the Brady standard. The Supreme Court of Kansas affirmed the district court’s denial of the motion for a new trial. View "State v. Anderson-Honeycutt " on Justia Law

by
The case concerns a defendant who, after being involved in a head-on vehicle collision, was found to have methamphetamine in his blood and approximately twenty-seven grams of methamphetamine in his vehicle. He was charged with possession with intent to deliver a controlled substance, failure to affix a drug tax stamp, and operating while intoxicated. The defendant moved to suppress the evidence obtained during the search of his vehicle and his subsequent statements, but the Iowa District Court for Scott County denied that motion. He then entered a conditional guilty plea to certain charges, reserving the right to appeal the suppression ruling.Following sentencing, the defendant appealed, arguing in part that the district court violated his right of allocution—his right to personally address the court before sentencing. The appeal was transferred to the Iowa Court of Appeals, which affirmed both his conviction and sentence. The Iowa Supreme Court then granted further review, allowing the appellate court’s decision to stand regarding the search warrant issue, but focusing on the alleged allocution error.The Supreme Court of Iowa held that the district court failed to comply with Iowa Rule of Criminal Procedure 2.23(2)(d)(3), which requires the court to personally address the defendant prior to sentencing and allow an opportunity to speak in mitigation. The district court had only inquired through defense counsel and did not directly ask the defendant. The Supreme Court found this to be insufficient and not substantial compliance with the rule. As a result, the Supreme Court affirmed the conviction but vacated the sentence and remanded the case for resentencing to ensure the defendant’s right of allocution is honored. View "State of Iowa v. Beamer" on Justia Law

by
A criminal case was initiated in Sarpy County, Nebraska, against an individual accused of first degree sexual assault of a child. At the preliminary hearing in county court, a deputy county attorney prosecuted the case, and the judge found probable cause to bind it over to district court. Defense counsel did not raise any issues about ex parte communications or conflicts of interest at this stage. After the case moved to district court, a different deputy county attorney was assigned, and the original prosecutor was no longer involved. Defense counsel later alleged, for the first time in district court, that the deputy county attorney had engaged in improper ex parte communications with the county court judge during the preliminary hearing. She sought to call the deputy county attorney as a witness, but ultimately did not do so.The district court, on its own initiative, considered these allegations and the purported appearance of impropriety, and appointed a special prosecutor from the Attorney General’s office, disqualifying the Sarpy County Attorney’s office from further participation. The Sarpy County Attorney’s office objected, arguing there was no evidence supporting a conflict of interest or improper conduct. The court denied motions to reconsider, and the defense never presented evidence of misconduct or called the deputy county attorney to testify. The district court eventually found the motion to quash the subpoena moot.The Nebraska Supreme Court reviewed the district court's actions in an original quo warranto proceeding brought by the Attorney General and Sarpy County Attorney. The Court held that the district court abused its discretion in appointing a special prosecutor because no evidence was presented supporting a disqualifying conflict of interest under the relevant statute. The appearance of impropriety alone was insufficient, and the conflict was not shown to affect the entire county attorney’s office. The Court ordered judgment of ouster, reinstating the Sarpy County Attorney’s office to the prosecution and removing the Attorney General’s office as special prosecutor. View "State ex rel. Hilgers v. Herman" on Justia Law

by
The appellant was serving prison sentences at the Nebraska Correctional Center for Women and became involved in a physical altercation with another inmate, Ashley Wood. The incident occurred inside Wood’s cell in the early hours of the morning, a location Prestige was not permitted to enter under prison rules. Testimony at trial showed Prestige entered the cell and engaged in a fight with Wood. Correctional officers and other inmates described Prestige as the aggressor, and there was evidence Prestige admitted to striking Wood, though Prestige later denied this admission and claimed she acted in self-defense after being attacked. Tensions between Prestige and Wood were documented prior to the incident.The District Court for York County held a jury trial at which Prestige was convicted of second degree assault and sentenced as a habitual criminal. Prestige, represented by new counsel, appealed, raising claims that the district court failed to conduct a hearing on the voluntariness of her post-incident statements, wrongly denied a self-defense instruction, and erred by not granting a mistrial when technical difficulties allegedly impeded her ability to participate in the trial remotely. She also raised several claims of ineffective assistance of trial counsel related to these alleged errors and other pretrial and trial conduct.The Nebraska Supreme Court held that the district court was not required to initiate a voluntariness hearing sua sponte absent a motion by the defense and that the evidence did not warrant a self-defense instruction because Prestige unjustifiably placed herself in harm’s way by entering the other inmate’s cell. The court found no reversible error regarding the technical difficulties, as there was no showing of actual prejudice. Claims of ineffective assistance of counsel were either insufficiently pled, conclusively refuted by the record, or required additional facts not in the record. The Supreme Court affirmed the district court’s judgment. View "State v. Prestige" on Justia Law

by
Three defendants met two victims under the pretense of purchasing marijuana, but evidence showed the defendants planned to rob them. During the encounter, one defendant fatally shot one victim and wounded the other. The prosecution charged two defendants with murder under a felony murder theory, alleging the killing occurred during a robbery. All three defendants were convicted by a jury of multiple counts, including murder, robbery, and assault with a firearm. Sentences ranged from life without parole to determinate terms. The surviving victim testified under use immunity, and both surveillance and forensic evidence corroborated the sequence of events. Social media and prior conduct evidence supported the prosecution's theory that the defendants had prior experience with robberies.Following trial in the Santa Clara County Superior Court, the defendants appealed to the California Court of Appeal, Sixth Appellate District, raising violations under the California Racial Justice Act of 2020 (RJA). Their primary argument was that the prosecutor used racially discriminatory language during jury selection and arguments, analogizing the defendants to a pit bull and ocean predators and prey. Although defense counsel had not objected to these statements at trial, the appellate court determined that the issue was sufficiently preserved because a prospective juror objected, and the trial court rejected the objection.The California Court of Appeal, Sixth Appellate District, held that the prosecutor's animal comparisons constituted racially discriminatory language under the RJA, as an objective observer would understand them as appealing to racial bias. The court found this to be a violation of the RJA and vacated the convictions and sentences, remanding the case for further proceedings consistent with Penal Code section 745(a). The court also found sufficient evidence to support the felony murder and robbery convictions for two defendants. The judgment was reversed and the matter remanded to the trial court. View "People v. Diaz" on Justia Law

by
In December 2019, the People charged the petitioner with assault with a deadly weapon after he allegedly threw large rocks at another individual during an altercation. The Superior Court of San Diego County found him incompetent to stand trial in early 2020 and committed him to a state hospital for up to two years. After his commitment expired and medical professionals determined he was not likely to regain competency, the trial court ordered his release in February 2022 but did not dismiss the charges from the 2019 case.More than three and a half years later, in November 2025, the petitioner was charged with a new, unrelated assault with a deadly weapon. After a competency evaluation was conducted in the new case, the court found him competent to stand trial. The prosecution then asked the trial court to use this competency finding to reinstate proceedings in the unresolved 2019 case. Over defense objection, the trial court agreed and reinstated the old charges. Defense counsel moved for reconsideration, arguing that the court lacked statutory authority to revive the 2019 case in this manner, but the trial court denied the request.The California Court of Appeal, Fourth Appellate District, Division One, reviewed the matter on a petition for writ of mandate. The court held that, under California’s statutory scheme for mental competency in criminal proceedings, there is no authority for a trial court to reinstate a previously suspended criminal case based solely on a finding of competence in a different, later case. Instead, the prosecution must dismiss and refile the charges to restart competency proceedings. The appellate court ordered the trial court to vacate its order reinstating the 2019 case and to deny the prosecution’s request to reinstate those proceedings. View "Pratt v. Super. Ct." on Justia Law

by
An individual became the subject of an FBI investigation after law enforcement discovered his online activities promoting violent jihadist materials and expressing a desire to attack the United States. Undercover FBI agents corresponded with him, leading him to plan a terrorist attack on a Chicago restaurant, though the bomb provided was inert due to the FBI’s involvement. After his arrest, while in custody, he solicited the murder of an undercover FBI agent and later attacked a fellow inmate with improvised weapons over a religious dispute.Following these events, he was found incompetent to stand trial due to mental health issues but was later deemed competent after treatment. As his cases proceeded in the United States District Court for the Northern District of Illinois, he entered an Alford plea to all charges. The district court initially sentenced him to 16 years, but the United States Court of Appeals for the Seventh Circuit found that sentence substantively unreasonable and remanded for resentencing. During post-remand proceedings, he changed attorneys multiple times, ultimately choosing to represent himself at sentencing, a decision the district court permitted after a thorough inquiry. The district court then imposed a 27-year sentence.On appeal to the United States Court of Appeals for the Seventh Circuit, he challenged the denial of his motion to withdraw his Alford plea, the validity of his waiver of counsel at sentencing, and the substantive reasonableness of his sentence. The court held that the district court did not abuse its discretion in denying the motion to withdraw the plea, found his waiver of counsel to be knowing and voluntary, and determined that the 27-year sentence was substantively reasonable. The district court’s judgment was affirmed. View "USA v Daoud" on Justia Law